Cafes

Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe

4.3 675 reviews Closed 712 College St, Toronto, ON M6G 1C3, Canada

Discover this place

Located in the vibrant heart of Toronto, Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe presents an inviting atmosphere that beckons lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. Reviews highlight its delicious paninis, perfect for a quick bite, with offerings like the Prosciutto and Turkey, both priced at CA$12.75. Customers rave about the café's dessert game, especially the Tartufo and customizable waffles, which have garnered praise for their exquisite flavors, especially the delightful tiramisu ice cream.

Though the desserts often shine, some diners express mixed feelings about certain items, such as the pistachio gelato, with a few noting it lacked authenticity and depth of flavor. Service has received critique on busy days, where wait times can be long, potentially impacting the overall experience. However, many guests appreciate the friendly staff and the cozy ambiance, making it a charming spot to unwind.

Customers like Geeta and Vedika highlight the café’s award-winning gelato, calling it “gelatinous delicious” and a must-try. With its generous portions and a welcoming vibe, Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe remains a top destination for those seeking quality Italian fare and delectable desserts in Toronto.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Great coffee
Great dessert
Great tea selection

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining
Good for working on laptop

Dining options

Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Historic
Trendy

Crowd

College students
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe before visiting.

Reviews for Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe

4.3

675 reviews

100%

36%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 675 reviews

Public reviews of Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe highlight its strong reputation for authentic Italian desserts, particularly their gelato and customizable waffles. Customers frequently praise the rich, traditional flavors and the generous portions, with several noting standout items like tiramisu and tartufo ice cream. The cafe’s laidback atmosphere and friendly staff contribute positively to the overall experience. However, some feedback points to occasional inconsistencies in gelato quality, with certain flavors perceived as artificial or lacking expected ingredients. Despite this, the cafe remains a popular spot for both locals and visitors seeking genuine Sicilian treats, backed by mentions of prestigious awards and recognition in the community.

Anna Suki

Jul 28, 2025

Came here during the rush of Taste of Italy and was craving for Italian food given the lack of at the event. Ordered the aracini and the pistachio gelato and the aracini was crispy and packed with tomato sauce - yum. The gelato however, was a huge disappointment. The flavour tasted very artificial and lacked pistachios. The moment I saw the colour (light green) of the gelato, I knew it was going to taste bad. I would avoid at all cost. It was very busy on a Saturday but our waitress only served three tables and she moved at a snail’s pace. She was never aware of her surroundings and it took her 20 minutes to take our order and another 10 minutes ti give us our bills. All in the meanwhile she was chitchatting with her colleagues. Tall, slim figure with a very long ponytail - didn’t catch her name but she was not good at serving at all.

Gauri Porwal

Jul 24, 2025

Really loved their Tartufo! Can’t wait to go back and try different menu items.

vedika kaushik

Jul 14, 2025

Sicilian Sidewalk Cafe truly nails the dessert game! The customisable waffles were an absolute highlight—pairing vanilla and tiramisu ice cream was the perfect combination. The tiramisu ice cream had this delicate yet powerful flavor that instantly won us over. My friend loved it so much, they’re planning another trip from Hamilton just for more! The atmosphere was laid-back and enjoyable, though a cozy booth or couch section would take it to the next level - highly suggest that for the cafe. Overall, it’s a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth looking for quality desserts in a welcoming setting!

Geeta Chand

Jul 09, 2025

The best Sicilian Side Walk Cafe in Toronto. Gelatinous delicious authentic Italian ice cream shop. Won many prestigious awards for their menu. Stop by if you are in the area and treat yourself.

Taylor Smith

May 22, 2025

Best ice-cream ever. The girls that work there are sweethearts and the scoops are generous

Like Clubs

May 15, 2025

Awesome coffee and service. Mario an awesome guy, fantastic coffee and cannoli and absolutely great charcuterie boards. You HAVE to visit this place, you will definitely have to visit again.

shuflbot123

May 03, 2025

Has a good Nutella taste to it, you should try it (ps service is a little slow as you can see